Dominic Kates
— Dylan
Cody Steele
— Ethan
Aimee Theresa
— Emily
Devin Kates
— Seth
Mark Cray
— John
Giancarlo French
— Dylan (Age 6) (voice)
Bill Ushler
— Detective Michael Hanlon
Erica Soto
— Alena
Dakota Skye Kates
— Robin
Roger Conners
— Ryder
Roberto Lombardi
— Joe Moretti
David Holbrook
— Dylan (Reenactment)
Vincent Wolfe
— Seth (Reenactment)
Sean Merritt
— John (Reenactment)
Alaina Walsh
— Tara (Reenactment)
Brynn Casapulla
— Robin (Reenactment)
Bruce A. Wolfe
— Detective (Reenactment)
Jeff Dillon
— Drug Dealer (Reenactment)
Dana Walsh
— Samantha Hayden (Reenactment)
Chris Woodcock
— Robert Hayden (Reenactment)
Fearon Derry
— Newcaster
Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.
— Crime Scene Detective
Tony J. Spadaccini
— Crime Scene Detective
Todd Kaylor
— Crime Scene Detective