Corinna Harney
— Melissa Curtis
Drew Johnson
— Danny Foster
David A. Burr
— Paul Ford
Ashleigh Synder
— Young Melissa Curtis
Ryan Sparks
— Young Danny Foster
Brittan Camden
— Bully 1
Stephen Retchless
— Bully 2
Chris Stanley
— Radio Voice (voice)
Jake Torem
— D.J. Voice (voice)
Donald Turner
— John Thomas
Michael Shapiro
— Joey
Robert Blomstrom
— Guy in Car with Joey
John Saxon
— Michael Curtis
Colin Ward
— Cop 1
Gregory Hamm
— Cop 2
Carole Vakanas
— Aunt Judy
Emerald Rachael Godfrey
— Rachel (as Emerald Godfrey)
Debbie McLeod
— Karen Foster
Darin Kuhlmann
— TV Baseball Announcer
David Giammarco
— Canadian Scout
Ibrahim Muhammad
— Young John Thomas
Jerry Ludlam
— Little League Ump
Dominic Cherico
— Quincy
Donna Baldwin
— Carole Curtis
Ethel Robins Richards
— High School Teacher
Dave Brinkley
— Eulogy V.O. (voice) (as Pastor Dave Brinkley)
Corey Page
— Vince Taylor
Leonard Gainey
— High School Ump
Paul Burr
— High School Coach
Randy Sutton
— Joe