Eric Roberts
— Parley Hinkins
Peter Stormare
— Prince of Doubt
Sally Kirkland
— Jeena
Jsu Garcia
— Jesus
Howard Lazar
— Older J-R
Sara Malakul Lane
— Maylene
Rick Ojeda
— Rick
Sebastian Michael Barr
— J-R as a Child
Nina Bergman
— Nina
Matthew Albert Cole
— Matt Coal (as Matthew Cole)
Bill Cox
— Coal Miner
Claudia Craciun
— Evil
Brandyn Cross
— Staff Jones
Laura Eichhorn
— Archangel Gabriel
Jules Douglas
— Jaisinha
Kaley Victoria Rose
— Mental Patient
Dylan Ramsey
— Raja
Lucretia Stillwater
— Mental Patient