Agnes

Molly C. Quinn

— Sister Mary

Jake Horowitz

— Benjamin

Hayley McFarland

— Sister Agnes

Rachel True

— Sister Ruth

Zandy Hartig

— Sister Honey

Chris Browning

— Father Black

Ben Hall

— Father Donaghue

Mary Buss

— Mother Superior

Chris Sullivan

— Curly

Sean Gunn

— Paul Satchimo

Cait Brasel

— Sister Dodd

Cheryl McConnell

— Sister Claude

Azrial Greene

— Sister Mawd

Rita Scranton

— Sister Gertrude

Ginger Gilmartin

— Wanda

Bruce Davis

— Earl

Van Quattro

— Father Exley

Chris Freihofer

— Father Cappa

Ron Sutor

— The Bishop

Jacob Snovel

— Pete (uncredited)

Lorri Bohnert

— Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)

Garrett O'Brien

— Grocery Store Shopper / Comedy Club Patron (uncredited)