Julie Harris
— Sister Anthony
Trini Alvarado
— Beth
Andrew McCarthy
— Richard Reilly
Suzi Hofrichter
— Anna 1939
Betty Aberlin
— Sister Sarah
Nili Bassman
— Anna 1950
Imogene Bliss
— Sister Lucia 1996
Therese Courtney
— Mother Superior 1939
Lulee Fisher
— Sister Rose
Jessica Hecht
— Sister Mary
Shannon Holt
— Sister Lucia 1939
Lynne Innerst
— Sister Francis 1939
Chad Luberger
— Roy
Kathleen McEntee
— Sister Margaret
Zachary Mott
— Anna's Father
Beverly Owings
— Matron
Anne Pitoniak
— Mother Superior Francis
Collin Quinn
— Tom
Stephen Scibetta
— Police Officer
Jaime Shapiro
— Doreen
Daniel Sweazen
— Helicopter Pilot
Katherine Sweeney
— Terry
Cornell J. Wallace
— Harvey
David Whalen
— Sven
Angela M. Da costa
— Spectator
Tony Amen
— Spectator (uncredited)
Phil Nardozzi
— Spectator (uncredited)