Gabriel Diani
— Richard Scarry
Janet Varney
— Mary Best
Jonathan Klein
— Dave Ross
Etta Devine
— Ginger Sparks
Nancy Lenehan
— Mom / Mrs. Scarry
Barry Bostwick
— Father Jimmy
Simon Helberg
— Young Husband
Alina Phelan
— Young Wife
Jocelyn Towne
— Dead Girl
Harry Groener
— Auction Man
Cole Stratton
— Ed