Julie Anne Prescott
— Carmilla
John Dugan
— Actor (voice)
Rebecca Rinehart
— Lane
Heather Harlow
— Cherry
Renee Graham
— Candy
Bryan Wilson
— O.G. HSM
Tim Ingersoll
— Indiana Raider
Joe Valorani
— Father Grace / Fireman Bill
Paisley Blackburn
— Claire
Chuck Terrell
— Willard / Martin Scoreseasy
Joe Wilson
— Pipe Laying Pickup Artist
Raymond Kester
— Ron Hutchins
Bill Trittle
— Jim the Drywall Man
Dave Day
— Phil
Athena Prychodko
— Ally
Jason Newlin
— Tommy
Bob East
— Wade Carter
Nathan Bechtold
— Lloyd
Carson Woodward
— Damone
Scott Orr
— President
Eric Keefe
— Willard
Joslyn Eckert
— Agent Kay
Ol' Scratch
— The Devil's Guitarist
Brian Simmerman
— Bar Guy
Brandon Stamper
— Johnny O
Brent W. Black
— Hannibal Savini Myers
Chris Blair
— Barry McCockiner
Charlie Ours
— Agent Hackworth
Eric Schroeder
— Judd
Christina Newlin
— Molly Ringworm