Lisa Pepper
— Nicole
Kari Reynolds
— Grace
Ashley Shubert
— Grace at 5
Catherine Rawls
— Nicole at 5
Chelsea Alden
— Grace at 10
Justine Sprague
— Nicole at 10
Zephyr Goza
— Michael Gavtier
Elaina McBroom
— Sister Damian
Glenda Chism
— Sister Paula
Kelly Hill
— Sister Maria
Emile Hirsch
— Brad
David Koplan
— Jason
Tish Shania
— Monique
Chris Solari
— Smoking Boy
Breezy Twilight Glover
— Baby Grace