Bethany LeBerthon
— Young Jenny
Anton Hense
— Young Alfred
Morganne Kennel
— Middle Aged Jenny
Samuel Hattersley
— Middle Aged Alfred (as Samuel Hattersly)
Holly Kiger
— Elderly Jenny
Jim Ortlieb
— Elderly Alfred
Steve Engel
— Doctor
Ella Fields
— Wedding Guest
Anne Ramsey
— Elvira Parker (archive footage)
Kristy Swanson
— Samantha Pringle (archive footage)