Danelle Simpson
— Caitlyn
Marty Lathrop
— Sam Reed
John Horstmann
— Cole Donnel
David Krist
— Chance
Stephen Krist
— Jesus
Clay Williams
— Satan
Nick Osborne
— Connor
Tyler Kreiner
— Adam
Denise Wampler
— Caitlyn's Mother
Kevin Piotrowski
— Caitlyn's Father
Reagan Wilkinson
— Aaron
Ken Morris
— Doctor
Lou Kreiner
— Jason
Jeff Krist
— Gambler