Joshua M. Lester
— The Pie Guy
Skye LaFontaine
— Sophia
Greg Hirshland
— Garret
Sam Anker
— Tommy
Amanda Westlake
— Jackie Collins
Colette Freedman
— The Therapist
Charlie R. Parker
— Kim
Julia Fae
— Baylee
Keegan Ferguson
— Supervisor
Ed Regine
— Dad
Varda Appleton
— Mom
Shikira Saul
— Ex-Girlfriend
Neil Lars
— Nolan
Deidre Lee
— Goth Girl
Amanda Rivers
— July
Dante Bisson
— Barry (TV Show)
Louie Caceres
— Pie Bartender
August Edwards
— Ryan
Jorge Espinoza
— Leonard (TV Show)
Laurie Gray
— Pie Bar Owner
Carolina Montenegro
— Emily
Arielle Raycene
— The Blonde
Thomas Sapin
— Half Naked Guy
Logan Solberg
— Bartender
Eddie Streeter
— Brooklyn Pizza Worker
Elle Sunkara
— Dr. Stephenson
Colleen Tholen
— Co-Worker
Kaleb Tholen
— Co-Worker
Ndi Wilson
— Middle Bar Date