Denise Richards
— Monica Sullivan
Patrick Muldoon
— Shane DeSoto
Rhys Olivia Cote
— Ava Sullivan
Andrew G. Bennett
— Dominick Sullivan
Sal Rendino
— Jimmy Dean
Nick Principe
— Crusher
Taylor Vale
— Houdini (voice)
Blair Dinucci
— Einstein (voice)
Forest Quaglia
— Jackpot (voice)
Laura Poe
— Mrs. Hope
Chelsea Vale
— Detective Lopez
Brittany Toczko
— Young Monica
Joey Ambrosini
— Young Dean
David Gere
— Mr. Crause
Tommy Fury
— Father Riley
Jesse Figueiredo
— Troy
Stephanie Lyn
— Troy's Girlfriend
Amari McDaniel
— Waitress
Stephen B. Reid
— Groomsman
Chris Baldyga
— High School Teacher
Arienne Palumbo
— High School Student
Joe Samonek
— High School Student
Jackson Gower Taylor
— High School Student
Kiara Cruz
— High School Student
Esteban Cintron
— High School Student
Blaise Serra
— Wedding Guest
Chad Verdi Jr.
— Neighbor
Paul Luba
— Neighbor
Audrey Fratelli
— Neighbor
Richard Sprandel
— High School Student (uncredited)