William Clifton
— Jake Richardson
Lindsey Luscri
— Olivia Cooper
Bryan Lane
— Sheriff Robert Cooper
Jason Allen Wolfe
— Rev. Joseph Callahan
Ramona Midgett
— Amy - 1943, 1944
Dick Mintzlaff
— Herbert
Joseph R. Engel
— Frank
Daniel Byington
— Stan Drizzio - 1955
Benjamin Gaa
— Gary Ridamin - 1955
Matthew S. Sinopole
— Ritchie Belagromay - 1955
Paul Wendell
— Shawn - 1944
Jessica Boston
— Justine - 1945
Jason Christ
— Jake's Father - 1979
Julie Farrar
— Jake's Mother - 1979
Emily Haack
— Nurse Martel - 1944
Stephen Potter
— Doctor Wilmington - 1944
Carol Christ
— Jake's Grandma - 1979
Jordan Callahan
— Francis and Jake Richardson - 1979
Mark Dodson
— Harold Evrett (voice)
Todd Tevlin
— FBI Agent (voice)
Caitlin Voss
— Suzy - 1945
Lillian Voss
— Rachel - 1945
Joey Barnett
— Pete - 1945
Scott D. Muck
— Javin - 1944
Gus Stevenson
— Gene - 1944
Chris Grega
— Doc Miller - 1944
Stephen J. Heffernan
— Red - 1944
Patrick Voss
— Gramps - 1944
Mark Cange
— Buzz - 1944
Sam Starck
— Rob - 1944