Undertaker: He Buries Them Alive!

Mark Calaway

— The Undertaker

William Moody

— Paul Bearer (Manager)

Rodney Anoaʻi

— Yokozuna

Jerry Lawler

— Jerry "The King" Lawler

Juan Rivera

— Kwang the Ninja

Bruno Lauer

— Dr. Harvey Wippleman (Manager)

Jeffrey Jarrett

— "Double J" Jeff Jarrett

Scott Bigelow

— Bam Bam Bigelow

Chris Pallies

— King Kong Bundy

Chuck Norris

— Self (Archive footage)

Brian Lee Harris

— Impostor Undertaker

Jim Neidhart

— Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart

Ted DiBiase Sr.

— "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase (Manager)

Harry Fujiwara

— Mr. Fuji (Manager)

Jim Cornette

— James E. Cornette (Manager)

Owen Hart

— Owen Hart (Ringside)