Mark Bischoff
— Lulu's On Main Customer
Alix Kermes
— Lynn Travis
Michael Bonini
— Peter Menold
Jason Frederick
— Pierce Morton
Catherine Cain
— Julie Remington
Stefanie Bloom
— Madison Bell
David Otunga
— Coach Robinson
Allison Grischow
— Lulu Davis
Kenney Myers
— Mayor Jeff Kaufman
Katelin Stack
— Mae Kaufman
Jeff Timmons
— Pastor Mark
Ivana Grahovac
— Brooke Remington
Collin Weigle
— Bake-Off Attendee
Adam Smith
— Lulu's On Main Customer
James Julah
— Bake-Off Attendee
Peter Grant
— Bake-Off Attendee