Donald O'Connor
— Davey Crandall
Helena Carter
— Lady Sylvia Copeland
Will Geer
— Tom Botts
John Emery
— Governor Elden
Stanley Logan
— Lord Montrose
Kathryn Givney
— Lady Montrose
Hayden Rorke
— Malcolm Giles
Morgan Farley
— Caleb Nicholas
Robert Barrat
— Henry Morgan
Alan Napier
— Capt. Kidd
Glenn Strange
— Capt. Ben Avery
Louis Bacigalupi
— Blackbeard
Hope Emerson
— Mistress Ann Bonney
Charles McGraw
— Capt. Ben Wickett