Tommy Flanagan
— Michael
Gary Stretch
— Duck
Sarah Graham Hayes
— Amity
Dean Sansone
— Larry Gold
Keith Randolph Smith
— Lenny
David Fonteno
— Benny
Peter Greene
— Marcus Devlin
Torri Singer
— 8-Year-Old Amity
Eric Tonken
— 16-Year-Old Michael
Del Pentecost
— Southern Cop
Stephanie Silk
— Denise the Waitress
Michael McCormick
— Walter
Victor Mastroianni
— Jeff the Clerk
Jeff Shore
— Moe
Tania Deighton
— Jamie
Peter James
— Justin
Dennis Yeandle
— Marty Greenburg
Alice Saltzman
— Brenda Greenburg
Louie Leonardo
— Groom
Christy Payette
— Bride
Greg Cilmi Jr.
— Amity's Father