Anthony Giordano
— Brett Sugarman
Zach Garner
— Greg Taylor
Joy Shatz
— Sara
Malorie Bryant
— Malorie
Paul Valenti
— Jim Stouffers
Randall McNeal
— Renee
Jessica Ritacco
— Veronica
Artie Brennan
— Mark
J.W. Crump
— Jason
Karen Summerton
— Hilary
Tabitha Viadurri
— Heckler
Bill Coyne
— Agent
Christopher Aurillio
— Shep
Pat Byrne
— MC
Jeremy Senie
— “Saturday Night” Clive
Mindy Tucker
— Mindy
Angel Yau
— Angel
Brittany Lee McDonald
— Kaitlin Carrey
Tony Wolf
— Improv Judge #1
Gary DeNoia
— Improv Judge #2
Ronny Pascale
— B.J. Simms
Daniel Florio
— Jake Thomas
KL Thomas
— House Manager
Evan Brandon
— Showcase M.C.
Paul Cohen
— Host
Elyse Brandau
— NY Reporter
Marcello Hernández
— Marcello