Cyd Charisse
— Various Characters
Howard Cosell
— The Storyteller
Totie Fields
— Mother Superior / Goddess of Love / Noah's Wife / Witch Penelope
Milt Kamen
— The Town Crier
Guy Marks
— The Baron / Torture Victim
Ricky Nelson
— The Minstrel (as Rick Nelson)
Mickey Rooney
— The Executioner / Noah
Ann Sothern
— Queen Gertrude
Yma Sumac
— Various Characters
Robert Shields
— Mime
Lynne Thigpen
— Witch / Ensemble
Lorene Yarnell Jansson
— Ensemble (uncredited)
Billy Barty
— Artist / Costumed Characters
Danny Goldman
— The Executioner's Son
Judy Kaye
— Maiden