Shane Brady
— Dylan Bradley
Katelyn Nacon
Justin Benson
— Mystery Door (voice)
Aaron Moorhead
— The Golden Door (voice)
Jake Satow
— Hockey Trophy Jake
Owen Atlas
— Young Dylan
Mia Castillo
— Young Briana
Lauren Clark
— Savior Elf Lauren
Megan Riley Harris
— Hockey Trophy Megan
Taylor McIntosh
— Hockey Trophy Taylor
Collin Thompson
— Hockey Trophy Collin
Evee White
— Young Lilly
Sarah Noelle Eastep
— Savior Elf Arbor