Hamish Briggs
— Dexter
Connor Keene
— Nicholas
Ross Turner
— Robert
Roland Rusinek
— Maxwell
Meggie Jenny
— Judy
Patrick Wade
— Caleb
Rick Andosca
— Older Caleb
Michael Bonini
— Danny
Ryan T. Johnson
— Logan
Greg Mills
— Grayson
Philip Boyd
— Thomas
K.J. Baker
— Cindy
Matrell Smith
— Lawrence
Lindsay Anne Williams
— Susan
Bridger Trent
— Lincoln
Wyatt Morra
— Wyatt
Kacey Bair
— Michelle
Michael Carollo
— Pauly
Todd D'Amour
— Jarvis
Manon Pages
— Teresa
Larissa Loeffler
— Patty
Veronica Clayton
— Lawrence's wife
Zach Primo
— Chris
Daniel Williamson
— Mary's date
Cole Blaylock
— Juggler
John Bucher
— First Magician
Anthony Baker
— Second Magician
Joseph Harris
— Third Magician