Abena
— Anne Page
Gbenga Akinnagbe
— Mister Nduka Ford
Pascale Armand
— Madam Ekua Page
MaYaa Boateng
— Fenton/Simple
Phillip James Brannon
— Pastor Evans
Brandon E. Burton
— Ensemble
Joshua Echebiri
— Slender/Pistol
Angela Grovey
— Mama Quickly
Branden Lindsay
— Ensemble
Jarvis D. Matthews
— Ensemble
Jacob Ming-Trent
— Falstaff
Jennifer Mogbock
— Ensemble
Ebony Marshall-Oliver
— Ensemble
Julian Rozzell Jr.
— Shallow
Kyle Scatliffe
— Mister Kwame Page
David Ryan Smith
— Doctor Caius
Susan Kelechi Watson
— Madam Nkechi Ford
Farai Malianga
— Drummer