Lloyd Nolan
— Frank 'Butterfingers' Maguire
Carole Landis
— Kathryn Baker
Sara Allgood
— Mrs. 'Mac' McAvoy
William Frawley
— Sam Sloan
Robert Armstrong
— Danny Mitchell
Jane Darwell
— Mrs. Maguire
George Holmes
— Roy Collins aka Roy Anderson
Scotty Beckett
— Squint
Joseph Allen
— Walter Rogers
James Burke
— Umpire Shaunnessy
Roger Imhof
— Mr. Maguire
Matt McHugh
— O'Doul
LeRoy Mason
— J.C. Scott - Catcher
Pat Flaherty
— Pat O'Hara - Pitcher
Dale Van Sickel
— Stevenson - First Baseman
John Burger
— Jim Harding - Outfielder
Jed Prouty
— The Judge
Robert Homans
— Mr. Collins
Mary Gordon
— Mrs. Collins
Ruth Clifford
— Ruth (uncredited)
Heinie Conklin
— Team Trainer (uncredited)
Gino Corrado
— Paul (uncredited)
Bess Flowers
— Patron at Pegasus Club (uncredited)
Jack Gargan
— Reporter (uncredited)
Bud Geary
— Blind Man (uncredited)
Rondo Hatton
— Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)
Robert Emmett Keane
— Team Co-Owner (uncredited)
Mae Marsh
— Aunt Mae (uncredited)
Bert Moorhouse
— Reporter (uncredited)
Harry 'Snub' Pollard
— Baseball Game Spectator (uncredited)