Abi Van Andel
— Beth English
Joseph Moreland
— Representative Bill Wilson
Dwight Turner
— Travis Warner
Tim Perez-Ross
— Nick
David Neil Cook
— Ray Pearce
Matthew Utley
— Bartholomew Decoris
Kennedy Gill
— Madi English
James Dickey
— Danny English
MaryAnn Gramig
— Alice Pearce
Bobby Lacer
— Judge Ezekiel Rothstein III
Eileen Lacer
— Tab Tate
Leighton Voight
— Young Beth
Rachel Crain
— Teenage Beth
Terry Gabhart
— Coffee Shop Santa
Sandra Gabhart
— Coffee Shop Mrs. Claus
Michael Bucci
— Bartender (as Mike Bucci)
Bret Hopkins
— Attorney General Thomas
Brett Lempner
— Newscaster Steve Stark
Alex Kennedy
— Detective Dave Dewey
Beck Rosser
— Detective Linda Lacer
Brayden Lacer
— Older Brother
Matthew David Cummings
— Younger Brother
Carter Hurst
— Twin #1
Nathaniel Hurst
— Twin #2
Steele Smith
— Kid Waiting for Santa #2
Presley Smith
— Kid Waiting for Santa #1